International Society of Primerus Law Firms

$70,861,113.00 Verdict for Retired Machinist Mate & Nuclear Inspector

Brayton Purcell LLP wins mesothelioma verdict against John Crane Inc.

On Thursday, October 30, 2014, after a six week trial and one day of deliberations, an Alameda County jury assessed a verdict against John Crane Inc., an asbestos packing and gasket manufacturer. The jury decided that John Crane, Inc. was negligent, that its asbestos-containing products were defective in design, and that it failed to warn. The jury assessed $40 million in non-economic damages for Robert Whalen. The jury assessed $30 Million dollars in Loss of Consortium Damages for Linda Whalen and $861,113 in economic damages.

According to court documents, in December 2013, Mr. Whalen was diagnosed with pleural mesothelioma, a debilitating and fatal cancer of the lining of the lung, and has been battling the disease ever since. From 1964 to 1990, Mr. Whalen served for twenty-six years in the U.S. Navy aboard nuclear submarines as a Machinists Mate and a Nuclear Inspector. Throughout his time in the service, he worked with asbestos-containing John Crane asbestos packing and gasket materials.

At trial, plaintiffs presented evidence that John Crane knew by at least 1970, and should have known decades before, that asbestos was deadly, yet never tested their products for safety, never consulted the medical literature concerning the potential hazards of the products and failed to adequately warn users of the hazards associated with their asbestos products.

“John Crane, Inc.’s defense relied heavily on misleading studies, funded by the asbestos industry, designed to artificially create doubt where none exists,” said Jennifer L. Alesio, counsel for Mr. Whalen. “It is my sincere hope that Mr. Whalen and Mrs. Whalen will be comforted during his remaining time on this earth knowing that the jury was able to make their way to the truth and hold John Crane Inc. accountable for their contribution in causing his terrible disease.” Associates Jennifer L. Alesio, Esq., Heather-Ann Young, Esq., and senior trial partner Gilbert L Purcell, of Brayton Purcell LLP, were trial counsel for the Whalens.

The trial, which began in September, was presided over by the Honorable Victoria Kolakowski, Alameda Superior Court. John Crane Inc. was represented at trial by Daniel Griffin, Esq. of O’Connell, Tivin, Miller & Burns, LLC and Robert Nelder, Esq. of Hassard Bonnington LLP.

For more information about Brayton Purcell, please visit the International Society of Primerus Law Firms.

$70,861,113.00 Verdict for Retired Machinist Mate & Nuclear Inspector – Press Release


The general information contained herein is intended for informational purposes only. It is not intended to be, and should not be construed as, legal advice or legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances.

Find a Primerus Lawyer

Business Law News Consumer Law News Defense Law News International Business Law News

Primerus News Archive

  Select Month: Go

Find a Lawyer


Primerus Law Firms (A-Z) Primerus Lawyers (A-Z) Primerus Law Firms by Practice Area Primerus Law Firms by Location Primerus Law Firms by Language Map of Primerus Law Firms